Editor's note: Nicole Gelinas responds to the new rent-regulation laws passed by New York's state legislature and signed by Governor Cuomo.
This week, New York's state legislature and Gov. Cuomo renewed—and made permanent—the state's rent-regulation laws governing New York City.
Smart Policy, Straight to You
Don't miss the newsletters from MI and City Journal
Rent regulations do not help poorer or elderly New Yorkers in an efficient, rational manner. Nine percent of regulated tenants make above $70,000 a year; one-third have a college degree. Meanwhile, 13 percent of market-rate tenants live in poverty, and do not benefit from rent-regulation laws.
Ending vacancy decontrol—that is, stopping the practice of taking empty apartments off the regulated rolls once the monthly rent reaches $2,700—is a giveaway to newcomers to the city who earn nearly six figures. To be approved to rent an apartment at above $2,700 a month, a potential tenant must earn $80,000 or above, hardly a group that needs special protection from market rents. Likewise, ending decontrol of occupied apartments for tenants who make above $200,000 a year represents a new government protection for tenants who don't need such protection.
Giving judges new authority to postpone evictions for up to a year "if the tenant cannot find a similar suitable dwelling in the same neighborhood after due and reasonable efforts" transfers a portion of the responsibility for homeless New Yorkers from taxpayers to property owners. It also puts a new burden on other tenants, who must pay higher rent, or suffer worse building maintenance, to make up for the loss of income from keeping a tenant who cannot pay rent.
______________________
Nicole Gelinas is a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute and contributing editor at City Journal. Follow her on Twitter here.