Photo by Greg Derr / POOL / AFP via Getty Images
The Right shouldn't abandon conservatism's inheritance.
For both progressives and conservatives, Lindsay Clancy has become as much a symbol as a person. The public meaning of the case is that women — especially women living traditional husband-and-children lives—are suffering and as such deserve the kind of sympathy that, in American culture today, translates directly into political power. For those progressives who see Clancy’s victory as a victory for all women, there’s no disentangling genuine belief that she lost her mind from the desire for power. For conservatives who see the symbolic claim as a tissue of falsehoods, some in their anger turn against the criminal justice system itself, particularly the insanity defense and the jury system.
We disagree. We’re law professors who teach in these areas and host one of the field’s few genuinely conservative podcasts (“Rationally BASED”). Yet we think the Right is getting the Clancy case wrong. The problem is not the insanity defense, nor the jury system.
Continue reading the entire piece here at The Daily Wire
______________________
Ilan Wurman, an adjunct fellow at the Manhattan Institute. Joshua Kleinfeld is the Rouse Professor of Law at the George Mason University Scalia School of Law