Photo by Trevor James Robert Dallen/Fairfax Media via Getty Images
‘I was up-front about my deal-breakers,’ writes a 33-year-old man. ‘Staying in the New York area and having at least three children.’ Our advice columnist weighs in.
Dear Abigail,
About eight months ago, when my girlfriend and I started dating, I was up-front about my deal-breakers: staying in the New York area, building a home centered on our shared religion, and having at least three children. She agreed in principle.
I raised the three-child point at least twice more during the relationship. Each time, I felt reassured that we were aligned. Six months in, after we had fallen in love, we began discussing timelines for engagement, marriage, and children. Because we are both 33 and fertility is a real consideration, I proposed a timeline that would make three children possible. That was when she said she had never committed to three; she was only open to it, and currently wanted two.
That hit me hard. I have no reason to think my girlfriend was being intentionally deceitful; I think we misunderstood each other, or failed to recognize the difference between being open to something and being committed to it. But I come from a big family—I’m one of five—and I want to create the same dynamic: siblings, cousins, chaos, laughter, fighting, and making up.
Continue reading the entire piece here at The Free Press Paywall
______________________
Abigail Shrier is a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute and the New York Times bestselling author of Bad Therapy: Why the Kids Aren’t Growing Up.