View all Articles
Commentary By Richard A. Epstein

Boulder’s Flawed Global Warming Case in Suncor

Economics, Governance Climate Change, Climate

Photo by: Marli Miller/UCG/Universal Images Group via Getty Images

Its argument was built on a theory of deception that makes little sense.

Earlier this month, the Supreme Court oral arguments in Suncor v. County Commissioners of Boulder. The case Boulder, Colorado’s attempt to sue several energy companies for damages allegedly caused by greenhouse-gas emissions. During oral argument, Boulder leaned heavily on its claim that the companies had engaged in deception: that Suncor and other companies were misleading the public by trying to obscure or downplay the effects of climate change.

That argument has been flawed from the start, resting on basic misunderstandings of the law of fraud and deception. There is no allegation of a conspiracy, and no reason to think that even these two companies knew or said the same things to the public at any time, so trying them together would be a nightmare. The Court should recognize these defects and swiftly reject Boulder’s claim, which would otherwise open the door to endless similar litigation.

Continue reading the entire piece here at Civitas Institute

______________________

Richard A. Epstein is a Manhattan Institute visiting scholar and one of America’s most prolific legal thinkers

This piece originally appeared in City Journal